Martha By Mail Christmas Cookies

Christmas with Heirloom Gingerbread Cookies: A Tutorial & Recipe

Martha By Mail Holiday 1998 catalog.

Good morning, good morning! There are many good things that say Christmas to me and my family. A lot of those are foods. Of my favorite foods, gingerbread, is at the top of my list of traditions. Gingerbread reminds me of the good times when I was a child and my mom baking. I would come home from school and smell the wonderful cookies as I came in the door. It is glorious with a cup of tea and its history is long and interesting.
From the Tudor courts where royalty had a chef whose sole job it was to supply them with gingerbread to the lovely wood fretwork of Gothic and Victorian houses acquiring the vernacular name gingerbread, it is loved around the world for its taste and tummy-calming properties. Gingerbread is cookie to be made all year, but Christmas seems an extra special time for it. Perhaps it is the spices in the recipe that make it so holiday-happy. Here is my own recipe. It makes a lot, is easy to work with, you can re-use the scraps, it bakes well, and tastes lovely!


Heirloom Gingerbread Cookies

6 Cups flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
3 teaspoons ginger
3 teaspoons cinnamon
1 teaspoon cloves
1 teaspoon nutmeg
1 & 1/2 teaspoon salt

2 sticks butter
1 Cup brown sugar
2 eggs
2 teaspoons vanilla
1 Cup molasses

Mix together all dry ingredients with a wire whisk. In a separate bowl or the bowl of your stand mixer, cream together, butter and sugar, then add eggs and vanilla. Mix in dry ingredients and molasses altering cups of each until done and a dough forms.

Divide dough into 4 balls and flatten. This dough works best if you use it right away but can be wrapped in plastic wrap and refrigerated. Allow to warm up a bit before baking with it.

When ready to bake, roll out dough onto a Silpat. First cover dough with a sheet of plastic wrap, then roll out with the rolling pin. Cut out cookies and gently remove negative or extra dough from around them. You can do this by rolling up the extra dough with your finger once you pull up a piece. Bake for 10 minutes in a 350 Farenheit oven. Let cool on the Silpat on the cookie sheet while another batch bakes. Then transfer carefully with a metal spatula to your storage container. This way your very large cookies won’t break. Put layers of wax paper between cookies so they won’t stick together in storage.

Put a lot of dough down- you don’t want this to take all day!
Using the plastic wrap keeps you from having to add flour to the dough and surface. It’s so much easier.
Giant Martha by Mail cookie cutters: Nutcracker, Nordstrom Bear, Mouse King.
Start taking the negative dough away.
This is just one of the reasons to use the Silpat!
Roll it up with your finger.
Ready to bake!
Now cooling on the Silpat- don’t remove them yet!
Assembly line ready for the oven!

Of course you will want to add icing! Queen Elizabeth I had some of her cookies made to look like people in her court! Here is a “royal” Royal icing recipe.


This recipe walks you through both the outline/detail icing and the flooding icing. You will need two icing bags for each color you use.

You can use egg whites in this recipe, but be aware of the risk of food illness from possible salmonella contamination. My family chooses to use Eggland’s best because they have the best record of safety and we eat lots of raw or under-cooked eggs. When I make cookies that will be shared with other people I always purchase Pasteurized egg whites so as not to make others sick!

6 Tablespoons of Pasteurized egg whites or the equivalent of 2 egg whites.
4 Cups powdered sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 teaspoon water

Beat egg whites until fluffy. Add in the powdered sugar, vanilla, and water. Mix until smooth. This is the outline and detail icing. Put about 3/4 Cup of icing into a bag with a #2 round tip. This tip is small and works well for outlining and detailing. Keep the rest of the icing in the mixer bowl.

For the flooding/filling-in icing add:
1 teaspoon water
to the rest of the icing in the bowl and mix. Put this icing into a bag with a #6 round tip. Flood/fill-in the outlines with this. Once your base coat is mostly dry you can go back over with the icing in the #2 tip bag to make details.


This is a big learning curve. As much as possible try to get the color straight from the jar/bottle. Wilson has good colors. Country Kitchen (CK products) have excellent colors and are what Martha used. CK products are available on Amazon. I use a mix. Some, harder to mix colors I buy from CK such as their teal- which is the same color base for a lot of Martha’s iconic arcauna colors that she decorates even her cookies with. For everyday colors I just use Wilton. If you find yourself in trouble mixing, Wilton has a guide.

Color is a really fun part. Remember to go easy! Pastels are the prettiest with the dark brown of the gingerbread. My favorite thing to do is to use colors not typically associated with the season. Here are some fab ideas from the Martha By Mail catalogs.

Martha by Mail Holiday 1998 catalog
Martha By Mail New Year 1999 catalog
Martha By Mail Holiday 2001 catalog


How much time do you have? This is the most time-consuming part. I always reserve a separate day(s) for decorating because of this. Plan ahead! If you have more than one coat you will have to leave time for the coats to dry before adding to them. Drying time depends on humidity and warmth of the air, but I typically wait an hour then put on the second layer.

My favorite time and hand saver is putting on the base coat with a small angled spatula. If you make little swishing movements the icing will settle down nicely. It might have a few small waves but it looks fine most of the time. The other way is to outline the shape you are doing (which is much better if you have more than one color in your base coat) then fill it in, or flood it until it is covered with the color.


Details can be added many ways. Wet icing can be drug into other wet icing for swirls. A toothpick can be drug through a wet dot in the wet base coat. This forms a heart. Overlapping colored lines can be drawn to look like plaid. Sugar can be sprinkled over wet icing, left to dry and then the loose crystals brushed away. (This is shown in the pictures below.) This gives a lovely sparkly look. For more sparkle add nonpareils, or dragees (dragees cannot be eaten). Some sugars are sanding sugars and are colored or even look like glitter. (These can be eaten.)


When you are done let your cookie set. I keep the dining room closed during cookie making so my cat and dog don’t disturb them drying in their trays on the table. (Although last Thanksgiving someone left a door open and the dog ate a whole tray of cookies while we were away!) I typically leave them over night to dry completely before bagging them up.



You’ve spent so much time on your lovely cookies- now it’s time to dress them up! Big goody bags and your favorite colored ribbon can make your cookie gift extra special. Don’t forget to enjoy one yourself. They happen to be excellent with a cup of earl grey tea!


A Merry Christmas from Kansas Street to you!


1 thought on “Martha By Mail Christmas Cookies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close